Russian dissident film screened at Hoover

 

Lyubov Sobol at the Hoover Institute, June 24, 2025/By Patricia Leslie

Lyubov Sobol is a human rights activist, a former attorney for Alexei Navalny (1976-2024), and a Russian native forced to flee her native country to avoid another prosecution and likely imprisonment.

She and filmmaker Marianna Yarovskaya were at the D.C. office of the Hoover Institute last week for the presentation of Lyuba's Hope, a film about Sobol's life as a dissident in Russia. 

Her hope is that Russia will become a democracy.

Sobol has been arrested multiple times for her opposition to Putin and her campaign for freedom in Russia.

The film opens with the police banging on the door of her residence before they barge in to take her away again, the first of her many clashes with the Russian gestapo.

A 2021 article in the New Yorker says that at one time, Sobol was sentenced to her home every night and banned from using the internet or telephone, accused of aiding Navalny.  

She had to wear an electronic ankle monitor and was prevented from running for public office, declared ineligible by the government. She notably conducted an investigation of Yevgeny Prigozhin* and found that his company poisoned Moscow kindergarteners with tainted food. 

Navalny and Sobol are shown together in several clips; at age 22, she was his organization's first attorney and grew to become Russia's' second most popular public opposition leader.

In 2019 the BBC named Sobol to its Leadership category on its list of 100 "inspiring and influential women from around the world." 

Her efforts to fight for democracy in Russia were honored by a 2019 Sergei Magnitsky Award.

Marianna Yarovskaya, left, and Lyubov Sobol at the Hoover Institute, June 24, 2025/By Patricia Leslie

About 60 came to see the film and packed the Hoover's D.C. office. I sat beside a Swedish economist who, within 60 seconds of greeting me, said that the U.S. today reminds him of 1933 when Hitler rose to power. He said his specialties are the economies of Russia and Ukraine.

Hoover is a conservative think tank, associated with Stanford University and founded in 1919 by Herbert Hoover before he became president. 

Some of its alums include Henry Kissinger, Milton Friedman, and Newt Gingrich. Condoleezza Rice is the director. Its first honorary fellow, named in 1975, was Ronald Reagan.

Sobol, now 37, enjoys her life now in Estonia, but it is not home which, I gathered from the film, is where she longs to be. 

During the screening I was constantly taken aback by her bravery, confidence and determination, none wavering in the Putin onslaught of her rights.  She, driven by her belief that Putin is wrong for Russia, wrong for the world.

The film's producer and Hoover Fellow, Paul Gregory, worked with Yarovskaya on the documentary film, Women of the Gulag, which was short-listed for the 2019 Academy Awards.  

*Prigozhin was the owner of the private military company, Wagner, before Putin had him killed in an airplane crash in 2023. His death resulted from the rebellion he led due to disagreements with Putin and Putin's regime over perceived mismanagement of Russia's campaign in the war for Ukraine.

patricialesli@gmail.com

Justice Clarence Thomas has his own movie

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas in Created Equal:  Clarence Thomas in His Own Words/Manifold Productions


Comments by the filmmaker, producer, and director after the screening of his new film about Clarence Thomas were almost as interesting as the film itself.

An adoring, practically fawning crowd welcomed the first public showing of Created Equal:  Clarence Thomas in His Own Words last week at the Cato Institute. At the show's end, filmmaker Michael Pack and Cato's Roger Pilon, who served as moderator, answered questions from the audience until there were no more.

Most of the questioners preceded their remarks with "brilliant!" and "excellent!" 

In the film, set for airing by PBS next May, Clarence Thomas sits and faces the camera and talks about his life, beginning with his early childhood.  He and his wife, Ginny, sat for 30 hours of interviewing, Mr. Pack said, and it was difficult to reduce that length to two hours, which left no room in the film for contributions and viewpoints from others.

Mr. Pack hopes law schools and other colleges will pick it up. 

Michael Pack at the Cato Institute Nov. 13, 2019 for the screening of his new film, Created Equal: Clarence Thomas In His Own Words/Photo by Patricia Leslie


Archival videos and photographs made excellent visuals, supplemented with the few Thomas family pictures available.


Several times Mr. Pack said that Justice Thomas's life is a classic American story, a much harder upbringing he had than, say, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg (whose RBG has earned nearly $14.5 million since its release in 2018. Mr. Pack sighed).
  
In Pin Point, Georgia, close to Savannah, Clarence Thomas's father abandoned his family when the future justice was a toddler. His mother struggled to earn a living wage and take care of her children who roamed the streets when the boys were six and seven years old.

In desperation, she took Clarence and his younger brother to her parents to live, and the two boys delighted to find indoor plumbing and food on the table every night at their grandparents' home. (Nothing was said about what happened to Mr. Thomas's mother or his sister.)

His grandfather was a disciplinarian who instilled hard work in his grandsons, respect for others, and a keen sense of the value of education. Mr. Thomas says he  "really regretted," not visiting his grandfather before he died to tell him "how much I loved and respected him."

The future justice attended Catholic high school and at age 16, considered becoming a priest. That possibility led him to seminary school until a racial epithet after the death of Martin Luther King Jr. caused Mr. Thomas to leave. That was about the time a door opened at the College of the Holy Cross and from there, it was on to Yale law school.

Justice Thomas describes his career and work for Sen. John Danforth (R-MO). After climbing the legal ladder, Mr. Thomas was nominated to the U.S.Supreme Court by President George H.W. Bush in 1991.

Presiding over the Thomas Senate confirmation hearing was Sen. Joe Biden, who, of course, is included at one of his worst moments, to the delight of the laughing audience. 

Mr. Thomas says he had no idea what Sen. Biden was talking about in the hearing when the senator talked about "natural laws," but Mr. Biden announced to everyone present that he and Mr. Thomas knew what he was talking about. (You have to see it.) 

The clash with the testimony of Anita Hill consumed  more in the film than expected. (At least four in the audience were not Thomas fans, including me who believed and still believes Anita Hill.)

When Mr. Thomas learned his nomination had been approved, his response was a sarcastic "whoop-dee-doo." 

Mr. Pack said unequivocally that the justice had not seen the film but Mr. Thomas's wife, Ginny (quoted extensively in it), had.

More than once Mr. Pack said the justice wanted to get his words out.  Clearly, Mr. Thomas still carries a chip on his shoulder which he probably has borne throughout life.

The documentary is an unbalanced portrayal but an autobiography, a hagiography someone suggested today, nonetheless. Mr. Thomas, 71, is now the most senior associate justice on the Supreme Court.

Mr. Pack's company, Manifold Productions, produced the film, with the help of his wife, Gina, a Manifold vice-president, who was also present.  

She urged her husband to shorten Words which is good advice! With redundant scenes of an unmanned boat gliding through Georgian marshes, I say, "cut!"

The banjo and piano made excellent accompaniment in the film as did the guest reception which preceded the showing.

patricialesli@gmail.com