Helen McNicoll, Midsummer, c. 1909, Art Gallery of Nova Scotia
Helen McNicoll, Study of a Child, c. 1913, Montreal Museum of Fine Arts. Although McNicoll never used the word "mother" in any of her titles, she often painted women as caregivers, working in and around the home. The label noted that McNicoll joined Mary Cassatt and Berthe Morisot describing the value of women's work, juxtaposed beside subjects chosen by male artists.
Helen McNicoll, Beneath the Trees, c. 1910, McNicoll Canadian Art Collection
Helen McNicoll, Garden, 1913, Pierre Lassonde Collection
Helen McNicoll, Garden (detail), 1913, Pierre Lassonde Collection
Upon first glance her style immediately brings to mind that of Mary Cassatt with whom she shared many commonalities.
The two artists often lived about the same time, McNicoll (1879-1915) and Cassatt (1844-1926). They spent part of their adult lives studying and painting abroad, in London (McNicoll) and France (Cassatt).
Helen McNicoll, Picking Flowers, c. 1912, Art Gallery of Ontario. The label said this was likely made when McNicoll was traveling and based on a plein-air study.Helen McNicoll, Fishing, c. 1907, private collection. McNicoll's companion, Dorothea Sharp, carried "pretty frocks" which fishermen's children loved to wear when modeling for the artist. See below.
Helen McNicoll, The Children's Playground, 1912, private collection.
Helen McNicoll, Landscape, c. 1910, Samuel and Esther Sarick Collection
Neither married nor had children. They shared a close bond with female companions. Both came from wealthy families.
At the outbreak of World War I in 1914, McNicoll was in France, soon forced home by her father. She died the next year in England.
Helen McNicoll, Venice, 1910, Pierre Lassonde CollectionHelen McNicoll, The Open Door, c. 1913, Samuel and Esther Sarick Collection.
Helen McNicoll, The Gleaner, 1910, Pierre Lassonde Collection. Her face seems a bit rough for a woman as she almost sneers. Unhappy in her work?
Helen McNicoll, Stubble Fields, c. 1912, National Gallery of Canada. Shortly after this was exhibited, it was purchased by the National Gallery which, the label noted, boosted the artist's confidence.
Helen McNicoll, This Gleaner was painted in 1908, again with a red, rough face, almost identical to the Gleaner above, painted two years later and in similar apparel. Samuel and Esther Sarick Collection
Helen McNicoll, The Chintz Sofa, 1913, Pierre Lassonde Collection. The woman may be Dorothea Sharp who shared this studio with McNicoll in London. The label said the woman pictured may be sewing mementos for the women's suffrage campaign in England. This work in 2023 produced the highest price, $653,775, that I found for a McNicoll.
Helen McNicoll, The Victorian Dress, c. 1914, Art Canada Institute
Helen McNicoll, Evening Street Scene, c. 1910, Women's Art Association of Canada
Helen McNicoll,, The Avenue, 1912, Pierre Lassonde Collection. This reminds me of several of van Gogh's.
Helen McNicoll, Montreal Snowstorm, c. 1911, Pierre Lassonde Collection
Helen McNicoll, Fruit Vendor, 1910, Pierre Lassonde Collection. The label noted that most of the artist's markets were French scenes but this one was in Venice. The girl wears a black shawl, then (and now) in vogue and shows three women in various roles.
Helen McNicoll, In the Market, Montreuil, 1912, private collection.
Helen McNicoll, The Market Cart, Brittany, 1910, Robert McLaughlin Gallery
Helen McNicoll, The Market Cart, Brittany, 1910, Robert McLaughlin Gallery
Unknown photographer, Helen McNicoll in her studio, c. 1906, Robert McLaughlin Gallery Archives
Helen McNicoll, Dorothea Sharp working with a child model, n.d., Robert McLaughlin Gallery Archives
McNicoll and Cassatt each suffered ill health, complications from diabetes leading to McNicoll's early death at age 35. At age 2, she had scarlet fever which left her practically deaf and unable to communicate normally.
And although she lived to age 82, Cassatt gave up painting at age 60 or 70 (sources vary) due to blindness.
In 2023 their art did meet in Cassatt — McNicoll: Impressionists Between Worlds at the Art Gallery of Ontario which has featured solo McNicoll exhibitions in the past.
I am sure there are other similarities which must be the subject of a dissertation or two. Here is a link is to a good article about the two artists in Art Herstory.
Searching Washington museums (the Phillips, the National Museum of Women in the Arts, the National Gallery of Art), I found none with a McNicoll but they all have at least one Cassatt. Yes: Cassatt was American, but still...
The highest price I found for a McNicoll was one she made likely of her companion, Dorothea Sharp, The Chintz Sofa (c.1912) which sold for $653,775 in 2023. Cassatt's high price was almost $7.4 million in 2022 for Young Lady in a Loge Gazing to Right.
patricialesli@gmail.com